For Want Of Normalcy

     At least of a familiar, if not superficial, variety.

     In many ways, much of the growing Leftism, from Woodrow spits Wilson and FDR, became normalized in the aftermath of the 2nd World War. Now, that Leftism wasn’t yet “woke”, nor was it of the Critical Studies variety, but it was a consensus that involved increased acceptance of global governance, rule by centralized experts, and the acceptance of the government moulding society to achieve some future without either war or want.

     While there was the Cold War, antithesis to Soviet-led Communism was not the opposition to big government, in terms of breadth and scope, or even socialism of the non-Communist variety. For example, it was a consensus that there was no individual right to keep and bear arms. Opposition to this was a fringe idea—a conservative idea.

     But people don’t really think of that time as “Leftist” in a modern sense. In large part because while the substance of the zeitgeist was Leftist, the superficial aspects of a traditional society were not yet transformed and indeed protected through multiple layers of thick ablative cultural armor that America, thankfully, was better protected in than the rest of Western Civilization.

     So, while the Overton Window of the substance has at least slowed its Leftward crawl through society and more positively been not only stopped but reversed—the individual right to keep and bear arms being the clearest and most overt example—even as that cultural ablative armor has worn thin and various forms of madness birthed from Leftist ideology has intruded itself into the lives and communities of people who just want to be left alone with the normalcy of their lives and communities that they remember (or even just imagine America had).

     It is this loss or normalcy, either suddenly or due to the proverbial last straw, that many feel that they can tolerate no longer not just the overt madness, but increasingly anything contra to that normalcy at all. Their desire is to “fight back” until “those people” stop. While that may be effective against overt intrusion, it’s not very effective in changing the substance of the society whence such madness arose. But no matter—out of sight; out of mind.

     But this desire to “fight back” mentally results in associating the many rules, restraints, and even freedoms America enjoys with the ideology of the Left itself—and the substance of that rich history of our great American pageant with said almost gangrenous Leftism—rather than the contributing factors which have retarded its spread and which allowed conservatism to rise to challenge it, almost uniquely in America and to a lesser extent some of the Anglosphere. That association, though, has led many to believe that the “rules” (i.e. our fundamental and inalienable liberties, adherence to limited government, and distinction between people and state) caused Leftism to begin with! The “solution” they then find it to adopt the fundamental substance of the Left, in order to “fight like the Left” in order to mould society back to the old superficial normalcy.

     The “rules”, then are seen as contrary to the normalcy they seek; by and large this is due to those core underlying elements of America are far too often not the core aspects of their daily lives.

     That they gloss over the fact that it was society in those hallowed years that lead to the modern wokeness, and would lead to that or some other similar madness if repeated, just underscores how much of their fight is surface level, which by its nature will not and can not counter the underlying transformative change coming from the Left.   This is why one sees so much praise from the (purported) Right for Nixon, JFK, and even FDR!

     The consequence of all this is that any conservative who wished to protect that American substance, and it’s freedoms, procedures, and protections is deemed as the enemy for refusing to toss those things out and thus standing in the way of a “retvrn” that many pine for. This is very much an internalized Leftist way of thinking, where destroying the “system of oppression” is the only legitimate route and anyone not fully on board with the destruction of that “system”, including the rules that purportedly allowed it to happen, is part and parcel of those who must be defeated and placed neck under foot.

     This acceptance of the past Leftism, now renamed as being Rightwing and even “conservative”, indicates a broad acceptance of the core elements of Leftist thinking, with opposition being not against Leftism as it is the particular outcome that conflicts with the normal society that they remember. The superficial is conflated with the substantive, at least enough to believe that that is all it takes to get, and keep, what they want in society.

     To this end, some have advocated unlimited means to achieve the alleged limited ends of a “common good” approach to government. But this too is an example of a Leftist mindset that has already proven to fail. After all, if forming a moral society is a limited and enumerated end, than the unlimited powers will be as constrained as the regulation of interstate commerce in the Constitution was found to be under Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111 (1942), when the Supreme Court decided that growing food for your own consumption on your own property was deemed to be a form of interstate commerce because it somehow could effect it!

     Thus, the unlimited means becomes its own ends, and a fig leaf justification makes the protection of limited ends effectively null and void.

     But for many, just as long as they get the freedom to enjoy the normal things in their life, be it incandescent light bulbs or plastic straws, they will accept a benevolent unlimited power above them and presume those unlimited means will serve their desired ends. This is quite consistent with a corporatist form of government, over society just as much as over the economy, whereby they exercise freedom within that “common good”, but that freedom is ultimately a dispensation from the government whose “limited ends” are whatever those controlling the reins of power deem them to be. The only true limit is the vague and nebulous term of “the common good” which since it can be defined and redefined through tyranny and mutation to be whatever it needs to be, inalienable rights and any constraint of government be damned.   As Ronald Reagan noted regarding “democracy” as the old stand in for the idea of the “common good”:

“Our natural unalienable rights are now presumed to be a dispensation of government, divisible by a vote of the majority. The greatest good for the greatest number is a high-sounding phrase but contrary to the very basis of our Nation, unless it is accompanied by the recognition that we have certain rights which cannot be infringed upon, even if the individual stands outvoted by all of his fellow citizens. Without this recognition, majority rule is nothing more then mob rule.”

     All in all, it is the acceptance that the government can proactively shape society, and thus the people according to some higher notion, be it from a ochlocratic populist or some tiny distant elite, is an acceptance of socialism, broadly and more properly understood.

     That may seem an alien idea that old fashioned values consistent with socialism, but that old prejudice stemmed from the overt creeping Leftism pushing social changes that induced a reactionary protection of the surface normalcy in peoples lives and communities.

     This puts me in mind of a question an avowed socialist of the Left asked your humble author: “Socialism is to the economic benefit of so many people including the rural poor and others, so why do they reject it in order to cling to their old social values and beliefs?” That question answers itself: People, even if inclined towards that broader concept of socialism for society, value their values, beliefs, and ways because those things are what makes their lives as Americans feel normal. The counter-question your humble author retorted was: “If your socialist system is so overridingly important, then why don’t you change your social values and norms to attract their support?”   That this socialist couldn’t conceive of that, even when presented with the statement, was telling.

     But then, as it eventually would, socialists of a culturally more Right-wing disposition squared that circle and presented a socialism, with a collective or common good that people would be subservient to, that promised to not just protect, but recreate that fading or even lost and mythical past society and all the rose-tinted visions of an eschaton immanentized.

     Thus, we have a uniparty in substance that merely stands worlds apart on what final form that substance should bring. In effect: Different eschaton; same immantization. And with that comes the same fundamental outcomes and same fundamental failure—all for embracing what they wish to defeat.

This entry was posted in Progressives, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *